Thus far, federal loan modification schemes and state foreclosure prevention initiatives have largely failed in averting the foreclosure of homes and in helping troubled homeowners.
The following three schemes have been recommended by experts to help solve the foreclosure crisis and revitalize the housing market:
- Mortgage bond guarantees
This scheme was proposed by Jack Guttentag, emeritus professor of finance at the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School. Guttentag explained that the goal of his scheme is to persuade owners of mortgage-backed securities to allow loan modifications to prevent further foreclosures. Mortgage-backed securities would be insured by private mortgage insurance firms, which in turn would be backed by the federal government. The government would cover part of insurance losses incurred by private insurers that would ensure bond owners get their payments in cases of defaults.
- Mortgage interest subsidies
This strategy was proposed by James Grosfeld, former chief executive officer of Pulte Homes. Grosfeld asks the federal government to subsidize the monthly amortizations of homeowners who took out mortgage loans from 2005 to 2007. Grosfeld said that the loans released during these years were mostly subprime, adjustable-rate mortgages and Alternative-A paper mortgages, which are highly risky types that ultimately led borrowers to defaults and foreclosures. He said that if the government rescued financial institutions which involved themselves in highly risky investments, it should also rescue individual homeowners who took out risky types of loans that they did not fully understand.
- Policy of allowing home prices to fall to sustainable levels
This approach was forwarded by Dean Baker, co-chairperson of the Washington, D.C.-based Center for Economic and Policy Research. Baker explained that allowing house prices to drop to sustainable levels will increase demand for houses and reduce the number of foreclosed homes languishing in the market. According to the Standard and Poor Case-Shiller National Index, home prices across the U.S. are still more than 50 percent above their levels in January 2000.
Posts 